Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Main PageTheatrical

A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical Returned for a Limited Run at The Fabulous Fox

Jesse Labelle and the company of A Beautiful Noise, photo by Jeremy Daniel

 

–by Ashley Cox

 

Friday was opening night for the weekend-only engagement of A Beautiful Noise at the Fabulous Fox. This is a return visit for the Neil Diamond musical which originally ran during the 2024-2025 season. I have been anticipating its return since it was announced. I loved this show back in 2024 and I loved it again (especially because I wasn’t battling a migraine this time).

 

 

The story is based upon the life of music legend Diamond though the timeline is not strict to real life. The overarching premise is Neil, dubbed Neil – Now played by Stuart Metcalf, and his therapist, Danie Steel in the aptly named role of Doctor, somewhat battling it out during a therapy session where a jaded Diamond clams up at every attempt to be reached. A love letter to Neil’s lengthy career, it is also a letter of gratitude to real doctor, Lu Katzman, Diamond’s long-time therapist.

Jesse Labelle as Neil Diamond and Claire Marshall as Marcia Murphey for A Beautiful Noise, photo by Jeremy Daniel

 

I am able to see many plays and musicals, and one of my favorite aspects is seeing how different artists embody the same role. Polished is not quite the correct word but the 2024 cast was flashy and grand compared to this ensemble who really captured the sadness of these characters. Both groups are equally talented yet different enough that you haven’t felt like you popped in a cast recording.

 

 

Unfortunately, there were some sound issues throughout the show with mic cues being slightly delayed. The cast is large enough that voices were picked by other actors but a three-night show needs to be on top of its game. I imagine it was a known issue as the auditorium doors opened almost twenty minutes later than normal.

 

 

Having closed on Sunday, the departure marks a pause in the Broadway season for the holidays which will be filled with Christmas themed delights, including Mannheim Steamroller, LoveActually Live In Concert, and the Hip Hop Nutcracker. The schedule picks up again with The Great Gatsby whose green light will fill the stage December 22 through January 3rd, perfect for sitting quietly after the loud holidays.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *